Fan life can be measured using different techniques.
Engineers in the industry use either L10
or MTTF. L10 measures life by
assuming certain conditions of fan life distribution,
at which ten percent of the sample units are tested
and failed. L10 is calculated based
on temperature acceleration method defined in MIL-STD-781.
Testing is usually conducted under 70-80oC
MTTF or the mean time to failure is the average time
before fans fail. Failure is defined as one of the
following: 1) fan does not work, 2) RPM is 30% of origin,
and 3) rated current is 30% of origin. Usually, a test
batch of samples is taken to ensure that the probability
test is reliable.
Calculations of Life
L10 Life (the minimum service
life)
T (forecast)
= T (actual) x FCC
Where:
T (forecast)
= the forecasted L10 life under working temperature
Tf usually 25oC
T (actual) =
the actual tested life under temperature Ta.
FCC = the temperature accelerator =
2EXP[(Tf - Ta) / 10]
MTTF (Mean Time To Failure)
A.F. = e (DH/K) x ((1/273 + TL) - 1/(273
+ TH))
Where,
A.F. = Acceleration Factor is number
of fan failed at TL test divided by number
of fan failed at TH.
273 = is absolute temperature
e =
natural log
DH =
Activation Energy
K =
Bottzmann's Constant = 8.623x10-5
TL = tested temperature
low = 50oC
TH =
tested temperature high = 80oC
Life characteristics are dependent on the
combination of voltage, frequency, ambient temperature,
mounting altitude, environment, and restriction to airflow
conditions encountered in an individual application. The most dependent factor to failure,
however, is bearing and lubrication of the bearing.
Bearing Type
The relationship between the bearing and the
fan is a positive relationship. If the bearing runs breaks, so
does the fan. There
are different bearing types to consider. There are sleeve, ball/sleeve,
and ball bearing. The
life hours increase as you move from left to right. Sleeve bearing, compared to ball
bearing, tend to be quieter at the initial start and
relatively less expensive.
As for the ball bearing, it can operate better
under extreme temperature.
Sleeve bearings have a life around 30,000
hours or the equivalent of 6 years under normal, 8-hour
day operating conditions.
At the initial point, a sleeve bearing fan is
much quieter than a ball bearing.
As time goes by, however, the sleeve bearing
will start losing lubrication and will become noisier
than its counterpart. The life on ball bearing fans are
somewhat different.
The life of a ball bearing will, typically, last
twice as long than that of a sleeve.
At initial use, the sleeve is much quieter. But if there is a rise in temperature,
the sleeve bearing will lose lubrication much faster,
leading to faster thermal breakdown. Still, sleeve fans remain relatively
quiet up until the lubrication is gone; whereas ball
bearing fans get noisier shortly after it starts.
|